The 5 best website builders for insurance agencies

Last updated: 8 September 2026
RankBuilderEditor styleFree planStarting priceQuote requests /10Coverage pages /10Our rating
1YolaBest fitEasy to use, no coding required✓ Yes$9.95/mo1099.8/10
2WixDrag and drop with complete control✓ Yes$17.00/mo999.2/10
3GoDaddySimple, guided prompts✓ Yes$9.99/mo978.8/10
4SquarespaceOrganized section editorTrial only$19.00/mo798.4/10
5DudaTeam editor designed for agenciesTrial only$19.00/mo888.0/10

Yola is the best fit for an insurance agency owner with no coding background who wants a site that looks established from day one and stays easy to update without help. The templates look professional before you change a thing, and correcting a license line takes minutes.

Feature lists aside, the job is simple. Someone comparing two local agents scans what you cover, checks that you're licensed in her state, and sends one quote request.

We evaluated the leading website builders against three practical questions:

  • Can you give personal auto, home, life and commercial lines their own pages without hiring anyone?

  • Can you put your state license, your designations and the carriers you represent where people actually look?

  • Does it all hold up on a phone screen, quote form included?

Yola covers all three. One trade-off is worth naming plainly. A quote request here is a customizable contact form, not a rating engine, so the premium still gets quoted in your rater.

Key takeaways

What is the best website builder for an insurance agency?
  • Yola is the strongest fit for an insurance agency that wants coverage pages, credentials and a quote form live without a developer. The guided setup handles the structure, so your time goes on the carrier list and the license line.

  • Wix is best if you want to shape the quote request field by field and add tools as the agency grows. The App Market covers policy review scheduling and CRM connections, though the phone layout usually needs a pass by hand.

  • GoDaddy suits a one-person agency that wants the fewest steps to a working page, with someone to call at any hour. Support runs around the clock and setup is guided, but the templates look much like every other small business site.

  • Squarespace fits an agency that wants to look established and plans to publish coverage explainers. The templates and built-in blogging are strong, though there's no free plan, only a 14 day trial, and it starts at $19.00/mo.

  • Duda works well if an outside marketing team runs your site or you have several branch locations. Client workspaces and multi-language pages are built in, which is more machinery than one small agency site needs.

GoDaddy's templates run plain and Squarespace wants $19.00/mo before you've written a single policy, so for an agency that needs its lines of coverage, its license and a quote form stated clearly, the Yola website builder puts all of it in one editor you run yourself for $9.95/mo.

  • Yola Sitebuilder

Overall score:
9.8/10 (CLEAR WINNER)

Pricing starts from:
$9.95 USD/mo

Free plan:
Yes

What setting up your Yola site actually looks like

You pick a template, and the AI Website Builder drafts a first pass from a short questionnaire: a home page, a services layout, an about section and a contact form. Then you make it yours. That services layout becomes a page per line, personal auto, homeowners and renters, life, and the commercial side with general liability, workers' comp and commercial auto. Under it goes the part people skim for: the carriers you're appointed with, your state license number, your years in the business and any designations you hold.

The quote form is yours to configure, so it can ask for what saves you a callback later, current carrier, renewal date, the vehicles or the property address, and whether they'd like a competing quote reviewed. Editing later works the same way. When you pick up a new carrier or drop one, you open the page, change the text and republish, no request filed with anyone. If you need help the night before a renewal push, Yola's support is a real person on chat or email.

PROS:
  • Auto, home, life and commercial lines each get their own page, and you add or reorder them yourself.

  • The contact form is customizable, so a quote request can arrive with renewal date and current carrier already on it.

  • Templates look professional out of the box, which counts when someone is comparing you with the agent two blocks over.

  • Your license number, designations and carrier list are plain text you edit the day they change.

  • Starts at $9.95/mo, and the free plan lets you see the site before you pay for anything.

CONS:
  • There's no native booking, so letting a client pick a policy review slot means adding a third-party integration.

  • Mobile layouts aren't separately customizable. Pages come out responsive, but you can't hand-tune the phone version on its own.

Yola's best features for an insurance agency website

The list is short because only a few things decide whether a quote request actually reaches your inbox.

  • AI Website Builder
    Answer a few questions about the agency and you get a full first draft to edit instead of an empty page.

  • Ready-made blocks
    Services, pricing, testimonials, FAQ and contact blocks drop in already laid out, so building a page per coverage line is mostly writing.

  • Customizable contact form
    You choose the fields, which is how a quote request turns into something you can act on rather than a name and an email address.

  • SEO Optimized Website
    Page titles, descriptions and URLs are yours to edit, so a coverage page can target how people in your county actually search.

  • Mobile Optimized
    Pages come out responsive, so a prospect filling in the quote form on her phone at a kitchen table gets the same layout you built.

Yola website builder for insurance agencies

Who benefits most

Yola works best for a small or independent agency that wants coverage pages, visible credentials and a working quote form without paying anyone to maintain them.
  • You run a one or two producer agency and there's no marketing department behind you.

  • You represent several carriers and the list changes more often than you'd like.

  • You want the quote form asking for renewal date and current carrier, not just a name.

  • You'd rather pay $9.95/mo than a retainer for someone else to make small edits.

  • You want to build the site and look at it before you spend anything.

Create a professional, free website in minutes

The free website builder for small businesses, professionals, and online stores.
  • Wix website builder

Overall score:
9.2/10

Pricing starts from:
$17.00 USD/mo

Free plan:
Yes (with Wix branding)

Wix is a drag-and-drop builder where any element can go anywhere on the page, backed by an App Market of add-ons and a template library in the thousands. For an agency, that means a quote form you shape field by field and room to add policy review scheduling, live chat or a client area later, without changing platforms when the book of business grows.

The trade-off is the work. The mobile layout usually needs its own pass once the desktop build is done, and with that much freedom a coverage page can end up busy instead of clear. Several of the add-ons you'd reach for are paid extras on top of the $17.00/mo starting price.

PROS:
  • Place the quote form wherever you want on the page, with exactly the fields you choose.

  • The App Market covers scheduling for policy reviews, live chat and CRM connections.

  • Thousands of templates, so you're not stuck with the look every other agency picked.

  • The AI site generator gives you a first draft to edit rather than a blank canvas.

CONS:
  • The phone version usually needs adjusting by hand after the desktop layout is finished.

  • The freedom makes it easy to build a coverage page a prospect has to work at reading.

  • Starts at $17.00/mo, and the add-ons you'd want are billed on top of that.

Wix's best features for an insurance agency website

For an agency, the parts of Wix that matter are the ones shaping the quote request and the pages leading to it.

  • AI website builder
    Describe the agency in a prompt and you get a first site to work from.

  • 2,000+ designer-made templates
    Enough range to build something that doesn't look like a stock insurance page.

  • Business tools with scheduling
    Store, blog, payments and appointment scheduling are built in, so a client can book a policy review on the site.

  • Marketing and SEO suite
    Tools for the search side, which is often how a prospect finds you in the first place.

Wix website builder for insurance agencies

Who benefits most

Wix works best for an agency that wants to design the quote request itself and expects to keep adding to the site.
  • You have a marketer or a tech-comfortable staffer who enjoys layout work.

  • You want prospects booking a policy review on the site without a workaround.

  • You're planning a client area or a memberships section later on.

  • You have a specific design in mind and want to match it closely.

  • You don't mind tidying up the mobile view once the desktop version is done.

  • GoDaddy website builder

Overall score:
8.8/10

Pricing starts from:
$9.99 USD/mo

Free plan:
Yes (limited)

GoDaddy's builder, now branded Airo, works from a prompt: you answer a few questions about the business and it assembles a working site with hosting, forms, analytics and SSL already in place. For a solo agency, that's the shortest route from nothing to a page listing your lines of coverage with a contact form under it, and support answers 24/7 if something breaks.

What you give up is design range. The templates feel generic, so two agencies in the same county can end up with sites that look related, and the free plan can't connect a custom domain, which matters when that domain is printed on your cards. As you add producers and lines, it starts to feel thin.

PROS:
  • Guided prompts get a coverage page and a contact form live in an afternoon.

  • Hosting, forms, analytics and SSL come with the paid plans, nothing to assemble.

  • 24/7 support, which fits an agency where the website work happens after hours.

  • Built-in email and social tools, handy for renewal reminders and seasonal pushes.

CONS:
  • Templates look generic, which works against you when a prospect has two agency sites open side by side.

  • The free plan can't use your own domain, so testing happens on a GoDaddy address.

GoDaddy's best features for an insurance agency website

GoDaddy's strength for an agency is that the plumbing is done before you start writing.

  • Airo AI site builder
    Prompt-to-site setup that gets the first version of your coverage page written for you to correct.

  • Built-in forms and analytics
    A quote request form and the numbers on who's reading your pages, without adding anything.

  • Automatic SSL and DDoS protection
    The padlock is handled, which matters when you're asking for a home address and a renewal date.

  • Custom logo maker and brand kit
    Useful for a new agency that doesn't have a logo settled yet.

GoDaddy website builder for insurance agencies

Who benefits most

GoDaddy works best for a solo agency owner who wants the least fuss between deciding on a site and having one.
  • You're the only licensed producer and the website is nobody's job but yours.

  • You want something live this week, plain and functional.

  • You already buy your domain and email in one place and want the site there too.

  • You'd rather call someone than search a help forum at 10pm.

  • Squarespace website builder

Overall score:
8.4/10

Pricing starts from:
$19.00 USD/mo

Free plan:
Trial only (14 days)

Squarespace is a design-first builder with polished section-based templates and strong blogging built in. That polish does real work for an agency: a clean coverage page and a tidy credentials section read as a firm that's been around a while, and the blog gives you somewhere to publish the plain-English explainers that answer questions before anyone calls, what an umbrella policy actually covers, why a higher deductible changes the premium.

The costs are structural. You work inside sections rather than placing elements freely, extensibility is limited with no open app market, and there's no free plan, only a 14 day trial, then $19.00/mo.

PROS:
  • Templates look established without design work, which is most of the credibility job.

  • Built-in blogging for coverage explainers that do the convincing before a call.

  • Hosting, security and a custom domain are handled for you.

CONS:
  • No free plan, only a 14 day trial, and it starts at $19.00/mo.

  • The section editor keeps pages tidy but limits how far you can rearrange the page around a quote form.

Squarespace's best features for an insurance agency website

Squarespace earns its place here on how the coverage and credentials pages look to someone deciding whether to call.

  • Customizable designer templates
    Polished layouts that suit a credentials page without you touching design software.

  • Built-in AI tools
    Help with drafting the copy for a coverage page you'd otherwise stare at.

  • Free custom domain
    Your agency name is in the web address without buying a domain somewhere else first.

  • Advanced website analytics
    Shows which coverage pages people read before they send a quote request.

Squarespace website builder for insurance agencies

Who benefits most

Squarespace works best for an agency that treats the site as a first impression and plans to keep publishing on it.
  • You want the site reading like a firm rather than a franchise page.

  • You'll write explainers on coverage regularly, not once and then never again.

  • Design polish matters to you more than the difference in monthly cost.

  • You're fine working inside a set structure instead of moving things freely.

  • Duda website builder

Overall score:
8.0/10

Pricing starts from:
$19.00 USD/mo

Free plan:
Trial only (14 days)

Duda is built for the people who make websites for other businesses: agencies, freelancers and in-house teams. It has strong no-code widgets, dynamic content, multi-language pages and a shared client workspace, so if a marketing firm handles your website, there's a decent chance they already work in it.

For an agency running one site of its own, that's more machinery than the job calls for, and the pricing follows who it was designed for. There's no free plan, only a 14 day trial, and it starts at $19.00/mo.

PROS:
  • A shared workspace, so your marketing partner and your staff work on the same site without passing one login around.

  • No-code widgets and dynamic content suit a branch list or a page per state you're licensed in.

  • Multi-language pages if a good part of your book is Spanish speaking.

CONS:
  • Priced and shaped for professionals building sites for clients, not for an owner doing it herself.

  • No free plan, only a 14 day trial, and one small agency site doesn't need this much.

Duda's best features for an insurance agency website

Duda's list reads differently here because the buyer is usually the person managing the site, not the person selling the policies.

  • AI website and widget generation
    Drafts pages and custom widgets, useful when several branch pages share a layout.

  • Multi-language website support
    Run the same coverage pages in English and Spanish without maintaining two sites.

  • Collaborative client workspace
    Your agency and whoever builds the site can comment and edit in one place.

  • Reliable AWS hosting
    Pages stay quick, which helps when someone is on a phone comparing agents.

Duda website builder for insurance agencies

Who benefits most

Duda works best for an agency whose site is handled by an outside marketing team, or a group running several branch locations.
  • You pay an agency or a freelancer to run the website for you.

  • You have several branch offices, each needing its own page.

  • You need the same pages in English and Spanish.

  • Two or three people need to work on the site without sharing one login.

Final recommendation

Across this comparison, Yola is the pick for a small insurance agency that wants its coverage lines, its credentials and a working quote form online without hiring anyone to keep them there.

For an agency moving from a phone number on a business card to a page a prospect can check before she calls, Yola is the shortest path that doesn't need a developer or a designer. Right now that prospect has no way to see whether you write commercial auto, which carriers you place business with, or whether you're licensed in her state, so she calls the other agent whose site says so. Yola closes that gap with pages you write in plain text and a quote form you set the fields on, at $9.95/mo, and the free plan lets you look at the whole thing first. Where the path runs out: the quote request is a contact form, not a rating engine, so the premium is still quoted in your comparative rater or the carrier's portal. If you later want clients booking policy reviews on the site, that comes in as a third-party integration.

When to choose Yola

Yola could be right for you if you want:

  • A page for each line of coverage that you write and update yourself

  • A quote form that asks for the renewal date and the current carrier

  • A professional look without any design work

  • A real person on chat or email when you need help

Insurance work is renewal driven, and the months when you have time to build a website are rarely the months with money to spare. Yola's free plan gives you one site with two pages, enough to put your main coverage lines and a quote form in front of a few clients and see whether anyone fills it in. The free plan has basic AI only and self-service support, and the full AI tools come with the paid plans, so you can build first and decide later whether it's earning its $9.95/mo.

When another builder might fit better

  • Wix , if you want to shape the quote form field by field and expect to add scheduling or a client area later

  • GoDaddy , if you're a one-person agency after the simplest guided setup, with support you can reach at any hour

  • Squarespace , if how the site looks matters most to you and you plan to publish coverage explainers regularly

  • Duda , if an outside marketing team runs your site, or you have several branch locations to keep in step

What to look for in a website builder

An insurance agency site has one job: show what you cover, make your license and carriers easy to verify, and take a quote request without a phone call first.
  1. A page per line of business , personal auto, homeowners, life and the commercial lines are different buying decisions, and a single page listing all of them reads like a menu nobody finishes.

  2. A quote form you control , the fields decide whether you can price something back or have to call to ask what the renewal date is.

  3. Somewhere for credentials , your state license number, years in business and any designations need a place a visitor finds without hunting.

  4. An editable carrier list , appointments change, and a site naming a carrier you no longer place business with costs you trust the moment someone asks.

  5. Mobile pages that hold up , a coverage page that reflows badly and a form that's awkward to fill with one thumb send the lead to the next agent on the list.

  6. Local search basics , you should be able to edit page titles, descriptions and URLs so a coverage page can match how people in your county search.

  7. Text you can correct fast , when compliance or a carrier asks for wording to change, waiting on someone else to publish it is the wrong kind of delay.

  8. Lead notification you trust , check where a submitted form actually lands and how quickly, because a quote request sitting unread for two days is a lost one.

  • Tip: Before you commit, build three real pages in the free plan or trial: personal auto, homeowners, and a quote request form asking for renewal date and current carrier. Then open them on your phone and fill the form in the way a stranger would, in a hurry, with one thumb. Check that the lead lands in the inbox you actually watch, and check how long it took you to get there. If an evening did it with no outside help, the builder fits an agency your size.

Our methodology

We compared these five builders on one outcome: someone who found your agency can see what you cover, confirm you're licensed, and send a quote request without calling first.

Running the site yourself carried more weight than the length of any feature list, because in most agencies the person updating the website is also the person writing the policies.

  • Coverage pages. Can you set up a page per line of business and reorder them as your book changes?

  • Quote requests. How much of the form can you change, and where does the submitted lead actually go?

  • Credibility. Is there a clean place for a license number, designations and the carriers you represent?

  • Phone screens. Does the coverage page stay readable and the form stay fillable on a small screen?

  • Editing without help. Could a producer with no web experience correct a line on a Tuesday afternoon between appointments?

  • Cost and support. What does the first month cost, and who answers when you have a question?

Scores reflect how each builder handled those tasks in real use, not how long its feature list runs.

Frequently asked questions

Why is Yola ranked #1 for insurance agency websites?

It covers the three things an agency site has to do, coverage pages, visible credentials and a quote request form, with no design experience required. Pricing starts at $9.95/mo and the free plan lets you build and preview before you pay, which suits an owner testing whether a site brings in requests at all. The editor is built for business owners rather than developers, so the person updating it can be the person selling.

Does Yola have local SEO tools for an insurance agency?

Yes. You can edit page titles, meta descriptions and URLs yourself, so a homeowners page can be written around the way people in your town search rather than a generic label. Pages are also mobile optimized as standard, which matters because a lot of local searching starts on a phone. Give each line of coverage its own page and each one has a shot at ranking on its own terms.

Should I list every carrier I represent on my website?

List the ones you actually place business with regularly and keep the list current, because naming a carrier you dropped last year is the kind of small thing that costs trust in a first conversation. For an independent agency, the carrier list is often what tells a visitor you can compare options rather than sell one product. Put your state license number near it, since a careful buyer will look for both in the same glance.

What should my insurance agency website include to get more leads?

A page for each line you write, a credentials section with your license and designations, and a quote request form that asks for enough to price something back: current carrier, renewal date, and the vehicle or property details. On Yola the form is customizable, so you set those fields yourself rather than accepting a default name and email box, and Yola's help center walks through setting up the Forms block. Keep the form short enough that someone finishes it on a phone.

Can I update my carrier list and license information myself?

Yes, and you should expect to. Those are plain text on the page, so picking up a new appointment or renewing a license means opening the page, changing the line and republishing, with nobody else to wait on. It takes about as long as writing an email, which is the point: information that goes stale on an agency site is usually information that was awkward to change.

Can I start with a free plan and upgrade later?

Yes. Yola's free plan covers one website and two pages with basic AI, which is enough to put your main coverage lines and a contact form live and see what comes back, then you move up when you want more pages or your own domain. Among the others here, Wix has a free plan with Wix branding and GoDaddy has a limited one that can't connect a custom domain. Squarespace and Duda don't offer a free plan at all, just a 14 day trial.

How important is mobile optimization for an insurance agency website?

It matters more than most owners expect. Plenty of this comparing happens on a phone, often in the evening after a renewal notice lands, and a coverage page someone has to pinch and drag around gets closed. Yola sites are responsive by default, so the layout adapts instead of shrinking, and Yola's help center covers how to check your content on smaller screens. Test your own quote form on a phone before you call the site finished.

Why is Yola a better choice than Wix or Squarespace for an insurance agency?

Wix gives you more control over the layout and a larger set of add-ons, and Squarespace's templates look sharper on a credentials page, so neither is a bad choice. The difference is what the work costs you. Wix expects a second pass to fix the phone layout, and Squarespace asks $19.00/mo with no free plan to test on. For an agency where the owner maintains the site between appointments, Yola gets the same coverage pages and quote form up with less to learn and less to redo.